On the Other End of the Line

By Michael P. Evans

A phone showing the Care Line number, 1 (844) 467-3473, beside a San Francisco Night Ministry sticker

Several weeks ago, before accompanying Night Minister Doug Binzak on a walk through the Tenderloin, I joined him for a video call. At the San Francisco Night Ministry office, Doug was talking over Zoom with a Clinical Pastoral Education student nearing the end of her summer clinical unit. She was volunteering for the Care Line, which offers telephone chaplaincy every evening from 6 p.m. to midnight Pacific time, seven days a week, at 844-467-3473 (844-HOPE-4-SF). She spoke about her evening, the beginning of the school year, and what lay ahead for her. We closed with prayer.

I didn’t think much about the meeting afterward. Doug and I were about to head out into the neighborhood.

But recently, when I talked to Director Rev. Benjamin DeShazo-Couchot about an article exploring the Care Line, he offered an account of a typical shift, drawing on the experience of what happens behind the scenes. And his description of the nightly handoff between Care Line companions and the street ministry team led me to realize what I’d witnessed.

That seemingly informal conversation between Doug and the student had actually been part of a nightly practice of coordination, reflection, and prayer, connecting those who answer the phones with those who walk the streets.

Sometimes the best intervention a chaplain can bring to a situation is what we call the “ministry of presence.” You’re powerless to fix a problem. Words may escape you. But you make an impact and bring comfort just by showing up. It’s deceptively simple and effective. Yet it’s one thing to bring the ministry of presence in person. It’s another to express it over the phone.

I know that tension well. In my work as a chaplain at Stanford Health Care, I have both inpatient and outpatient responsibilities. Sometimes, my outpatient visits happen over the phone. In those cases, all I have are my words, my willingness to listen, and even my silence. I’ve learned that presence doesn’t always require filling the gaps.

In the shift Ben described, one caller is experiencing the stresses of everyday life. The Care Line companion has to resist the urge to fix things. Instead, they remain present to the caller’s distress, holding what Ben calls “a non-judgmental container for her anxiety.” As the conversation unfolds, she asks for prayer. Just as the prayer begins, another call comes in, which the companion allows to ring. According to Ben, “We can only be present to one person at a time.”

That too resonates with my work as a health care chaplain, where triage is a necessary skill for navigating multiple needs at once. Yet presence also requires accepting that I cannot attend to everyone simultaneously. Sometimes I must allow other demands to wait.

The conviction that presence matters, even over a telephone line, has deep roots here. Telephone chaplaincy has been part of San Francisco Night Ministry for much of its 62 years. Originally known as the Crisis Line, it was established under Jo Chadwick, whose volunteers sometimes answered calls until dawn. In 2020, the service was renamed the Care Line, recognizing that people need someone to talk to not only in moments of crisis, but in the ordinary struggles of daily life.

I hadn’t fully appreciated that when I joined Doug and the student for their evening handoff. I was preparing to go out into the Tenderloin with Doug. She was preparing to offer her presence over the phone to people she might never meet. We were setting out into different spaces, but practicing the same ministry.

Next
Next

Sixty-two years of showing up